Skip navigation
Site powered by
Latest news:
msnbc.com: Top msnbc.com headlines: Kings win in OT, reach Stanley Cup finals

Don’t blame age minimum for college scandals

Requiring players to be more mature, receive more coaching is smart move

Image: O.J. Mayo Getty Images
O.J. Mayo played for one season at USC.

The business element of the age minimum is the most comfortable platform from which to defend its merits, but the rule is attacked most often from a civil rights angle.

"I look at it as age discrimination," Rep. Cohen said.

It is not at all uncommon for race to be introduced, as Rep. Cohen does when he cites that sports such as tennis and golf, in which the majority of players are white, have no such age minimum.

Elmore is comfortable countering that approach, as well. He believes if teenaged athletes see college as their best avenue to the NBA, they'll be forced to pay greater attention to compiling more presentable scholastic records.

"The burden of failure uniquely falls on young people of color," Elmore said. "That's our biggest problem right now. Far more kids are hurt by having these false hoop dreams than the ones who actually make it, and the reason is clear. They have this so-called path to the NBA, and it goes directly from high school to the league. How many guys have fallen off that path?

Slideshow
Oklahoma Sooners v Syracuse Orange
  NBA draft: The top prospects
A look at the top players available in the 2009 NBA draft.

more photos

"Maybe it's paternalistic, but that's been a problem in our community for the last couple decades. We haven't had enough paternalism."

Since the NBA introduced its age minimum for the 2007 draft, 25 players entered after a single year on campus. Not every one left a hugely positive impression on his college program, but for every Kosta Koufos there was a Greg Oden, for every J.J. Hickson there was a Kevin Durant. Only two of these 25 players — 8 percent — became enveloped in NCAA scandal. College basketball wasn't entirely clean before the "one-and-dones" arrived, and they haven't necessarily made it less so.

Before the age of the age minimum, many players stopped by college for but a single season: Carmelo Anthony, Chris Bosh, Dajuan Wagner. There is one way to legislate against that: a 20-year age minimum. If "one-and-done" is the problem, there's your solution.

© 2012 Sporting News


< Prev | 1 | 2

advertisement
More news
Image: Craig Robinson, Jared Cunningham
AP
Is this rule working?

CBT: With all the hand-wringing the media does in regards to the NCAA and its rulebook, there may not be a rule in all of college basketball that has been able to unite the masses like the new early entry deadline

Slideshow
Image: NCAA Men's Championship Game - Kansas v Kentucky
  It's Madness time!
See some of the top images from the NCAA men's basketball tournament.

NBCSports.com

College basketball videos
National champion Wildcats visit White House
President Obama welcomes the University of Kentucky men's basketball team to the White House on Friday.

Slideshow
NCAA Basketball Tournament -  Loyola v Ohio State
  Three cheers for college hoops
Take a look at cheerleaders in action from around the country.

NBCSports.com

Slideshow
Image:
  The Week in Sports Pictures
A kayaker flips out, a racehorse eyes the Triple Crown and more.

more photos