Skip navigation

Filly gives racing what it desperately needed

Gutsy win by Rachel Alexandra is bright light in sport beset by bad news

Image: Rachel Alexandra wins
Julie Jacobson / AP
Jockey Calvin Borel and Rachel Alexandra, left, stave off late-charging Mike Smith and Mine That Bird (2) and third-place Eibar Coa and Musket Man (3).
Video
  Filly wins Preakness thriller
Rachel Alexandra holds off Derby winner Mine That Bird to become first female to win race since 1924.

NBC Sports

Video
  Preakness Overhead Cam
May 16: Watch Rachel Alexandra hold off Mine That Bird on the overhead cam.

NBC Sports

OPINION
By Mike Brunker
Horse racing editor
NBCSports.com
updated 2:25 p.m. ET June 16, 2009

Mike Brunker
Horse racing editor

E-mail
BALTIMORE - Horse racing is called the sport of kings, but a princess put on a show in Saturday’s Preakness Stakes, providing just the right salve for a game that has recently had more than its share of aches and pains.

Rachel Alexandra joined the ranks of the greatest fillies to ever grace a racetrack with her game one-length victory over Kentucky Derby winner Mine That Bird, becoming the first member of her gender to win the Preakness in 85 years and just the fifth overall.

But unlike her victory two weeks ago in the Kentucky Oaks, this was no coronation. It was a good old-fashioned horse race.

Story continues below ↓
advertisement | your ad here

Mine That Bird let the gas out of the argument that his amazing last-to-first victory in the Derby at 50-1 was a fluke, mounting another impressive charge that came up just short.

And old reliable Musket Man fired his best shot yet again, repeating his third-place Derby finish while narrowing the margin to Mine That Bird to a mere half length.

Best of all, there were no injuries and no other significant distractions — the gray, rain-spitting skies, extension of the Triple Crown drought to 31 years and disappointing attendance of 77,850 at Pimlico notwithstanding.

It remains to be seen how Rachel Alexandra’s victory will resonate with the general public, or whether her freshly minted rivalry with Mine that Bird will be renewed three weeks hence in the Belmont Stakes on June 6.

But for those who love the sport, her performance in the second jewel of the Triple Crown will live for a long, long time.

While Rachel had been toying with her competition in her recent races, adversity looked her in the eye this time. She didn’t blink.

The filly didn’t get her customary quick start, breaking outward from the 13 post and losing maybe half a step to her rivals. Jockey Calvin Borel then revved her to the front, intent on avoiding a wide trip around the first turn, which accomplished that goal but left her eyeball-to-eyeball with speedy rival Big Drama rounding the first bend.

She stuck her neck in front entering the backstretch, but to Borel’s consternation she wasn’t floating over the Pimlico racetrack with the same ease as she had the five previous times he had ridden her. 

“The first quarter was good, then we picked it up,” he said afterward. “The more I asked her, the more she struggled.”

Even so, she managed to separate herself from the field at the top of the stretch and open a four-length lead.  For a brief moment it appeared that she was headed for another ridiculously easy victory.

Then the toll of her exertions came due. Her rhythmic strides began to diminish from allegro to moderato and she was clearly a tired racehorse passing the 1/16th pole. For the first time since she and Borel first partnered in November, she felt the sting of Borel’s whip.

But when the chips were down and the colts were charging, Rachel Alexandra dug into her untapped reserves and found something more.

It was a show of determination that was not lost on her rivals.

  Filly winners in Triple Crown races

2009: Rachel Alexandra — Preakness Stakes
2007: Rags to Riches — Belmont Stakes
1988: Winning Colors — Kentucky Derby
1980: Genuine Risk — Kentucky Derby
1924: Nellie Morse — Preakness Stakes
1915: Rhine Maiden — Preakness Stakes
1915: Regret — Kentucky Derby
1906: Whimsical — Preakness Stakes
1905: Tanya — Belmont Stakes
1903: Flocarline — Preakness Stakes
1867: Ruthless — Belmont Stakes

“I thought she’d come back to me, but she kept on going,” said Mike Smith, who ably filled the vacancy left by Borel on Mine That Bird.

“My horse ran well, but we got beat by a great one,” said Derek Ryan, Musket Man’s trainer. “She’s a filly for the ages.”

Trainer Steve Asmussen, who had the good fortune to inherit the filly after co-owners Jess Jackson and Harold McCormick purchased her privately after her tour-de-force in the Kentucky Oaks, also sang her praises.

But his post-race remarks also seemed to suggest that the still-developing superstar might skip the Belmont.

“The race didn’t unfold exactly as we expected it to,” he said. “She was still good enough to win a classic. She’s a true champion, a tremendous talent and deserves to be treated with the respect that she deserves.”

Jackson, the filly’s majority owner and founder of Napa’s Kendall Jackson winery, said that the team would seriously consider the Belmont, but he, too, noted that the Preakness was a tough race for her, saying,” she may be coming out of this much more tired than I know.”

© 2009 NBC Sports.com  Reprints

Sponsored links